From the Japanese designers, we all know MINE and Yuu Asaka, both know for the top quality packing puzzles.
I came accross a new designer who is designing and making plexi packing puzzle. What about the quality? What about the solve? Let's see that in details!
Acazu, the name of the designer, has made several packing puzzles and I was intrigued as nobody has ever reviewed it so far.
His easiest packing puzzle consisting of 5 pieces to pack. Don't be fooled by the mentioned difficulty, it's more difficult than you can expect. To be honest I randomly put pieces and....solved. Took me a bit of time but I managed to beat the puzzle! A good warm-up for his more difficult puzzles. Difficulty mentioned: 1/5. In my opinion it's: 2/5
5 pieces to pack with one circle being divided into halves. Will they remain together at the end? Sorry, no spoilers!
I am a bit disappointed by the puzzle because I found a solution and a friend of mine who played with it found another solution, his being more elegant. So I guess mine was just being made possible by a slighly tolerance issue. It took me way too long to find even one solution. So honetly the mentioned difficulty of 2/5 is not really accurate. I would give a 3.5/5
This puzzles has been submitted to the international puzzle party design competition but did not get any prize. I like the shape of the puzzles and obviously you will understand that the little small piece will challenge you. It took me also a bit of time to figure it out, but I guess this is somehow pretty satisfying. Difficulty mentioned: 2.5/5. Again I would give a 3.5/5
I would have expected music shaped pieces due to the name but the pieces look like more trees / candle, but anyway this gives a nice look. By putting the pieces inside the frame you will understand normally if 2 pieces could fit together and normally also at some point will be use a different approach because no matter you put the pieces in an "usual" way, they won't fit.
I agree with the difficulty of 3/5. It's easier than solahai in my opinion.
About the quality of each puzzle, nothing bad to say. They are well made. I am still a bit "puzzled" about the fit as it's pretty tight and one may want to push a bit the pieces inside the frame...Also as I said before I should not have been able to find a second solution for solahai if the puzzles was perfectly made.
Now, what about the solutions? (no spoilers!)
To be honest, I am disappointed by the solution. They are not very beautiful if compared to Asaka's puzzles. For Asaka's puzzle, you usually have a nice looking solution, sometime with a symetry. Here not at all, just pieces put inside a tray. Yes, that is the goal of a packing puzzle, but well...
Also the pieces are cut in weird way just to confuse you, especially for quarted and solahai. You will clearly see that you cannot fit 2 pieces without gaps. And that also gives the feeling that the design of the pieces are somewhat "random" without any intention neither to have a nice looking solution, nor to have clear "relationships" between the pieces...
Of course, if you're into (challenging) packing puzzles, they will suit your taste. From my side, he is not my favourite Japanese puzzle designer.